Draft · introduction and summary to be recorded · playlist link pending

Thread 12 · Empathy

Openness

Two Minds Meeting

Openness eases the awkwardness between people at its source, because the one who can afford to be wrong in company turns the person who contradicts them from an opponent into a partner in a common search.

The episode in three lines

Attention, not anger.

  1. Stiffness is two positions being defended.

    Nobody at the table is rude. Each is simply guarding a position, and the guarding has become the whole conversation.

  2. Smoothing it over rarely works.

    Change the subject. Let it go. The stiffness simply waits for the next course.

  3. A corrected judgement is still your own.

    Franklin, at eighty-one, took his age not as a claim to authority but as evidence that he could be wrong.

Where the episode begins

“When any one contradicts me, he raises my attention, not my anger.”
Michel de Montaigne, Essays, III.8, “Of the Art of Conference”, tr. Cotton, ed. Hazlitt

Watch

Three videos, one sitting.

Play all three
  1. Introduction 3 min SwissHampton

    Two Minds Meeting

    A dinner table gone stiff, Montaigne on contradiction, and Franklin at eighty-one on the value of being wrong: how openness eases the awkwardness of difference at its source.

    Watch To be recorded

  2. The talk 12 min TEDxPSU

    Julia Galef: Why you think you're right — even if you're wrong

    Galef asks why it is so hard to change our minds, even when the evidence is plain, and she begins with a story from nineteenth-century France. She describes two mindsets, and what decides between them.

    Listen for  the two mindsets, soldier and scout, and what she says decides which one we are in.

    Watch on TED Link pending

  3. Summary 2 min SwissHampton

    The Common Cause

    What Julia Galef's soldier and scout mean for the conversation across the table, where her argument meets the Thread and where it presses against it, and one question to take away.

    Watch To be recorded

The talk and the Thread

She agrees about being wrong. Less so about being heard.

Where they meet

That last point is the Thread's own. The security to be wrong in company is exactly what lets the dinner table breathe.

Where she presses against it

Here, though, she presses against us. Her scout is chiefly after an accurate map of the world. The Thread wants something more. It wants the person across the table to feel heard. Clear sight is not the same as connection. But I suspect it is where connection starts.

One question to take away

When you smooth a disagreement over to keep the peace, have you been kind? Or have you only kept your position safe?

Go further

Read the Thread.

The episode is the short way in. Openness is Thread twelve of The 48 Threads of Connection, in the book and on the website.

The Thread The book Newsletter